← All documents

document · Press release

Ali al-Sistani — supplementary: 2003 Bremer-exchange + elected-constitutional-council doctrine

English IQ flag Iraq 2003-11-29 245 words

Politician: Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani

Original source: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ali_al-Sistani</answer>

Content

verbatim · English
From Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani (b. 1930, Iranian-born Iraqi Shia marja al-taqlid based in Najaf; one of the four Maraji al-Taqlid (Sources of Emulation) for global Shia Islam; the dominant Shia religious authority in post-2003 Iraq; gave the foundational 2003 fatwas mandating Iraqi elections and rejecting US-imposed constitutional drafting; gave the 13 June 2014 fatwa mandating Iraqi-Shia armed resistance to ISIS that produced the Popular Mobilization Forces (Hashd al-Shaabi)):

2003 (Sistani to CPA Administrator Paul Bremer III, declining direct meeting and communicating through aides; this exchange is one of the most documented examples of Sistani's refusal to participate in US-led constitutional drafting):
'Mr. Bremer, you are an American and I am an Iranian. I suggest we leave it up to the Iraqis to devise their constitution.'

29 November 2003 (Sistani's foundational 2003 fatwa on the Transitional Administrative Law / constitutional drafting process):
'The council that will write the constitution should be elected, not hand-picked... The constitution will be illegal if it is written by a council, whether that is chosen by the Americans or by what is called the Governing Council or by anyone else.'

On Israeli goods (Sistani religious-ruling, on consumer behavior of Muslims):
'It is not permissible for a Muslim to buy products of the countries that are in a state of war with Islam and Muslims, for example, Israel.'

On personal asceticism (Sistani famously lives in extreme austerity in Najaf):
'People are not finding potable water and you're bringing me juice? No.'

How to cite this document

This is a third-party primary text. Cite the original author and source — Tayyar hosts the verbatim excerpt for research access, but Tayyar is not the author. The "Retrieved via" line at the bottom records your access path through Tayyar for transparency.

In-text (al-Sistani, 2003)
APA 7
al-Sistani, G. A. A.. (2003). Ali al-Sistani — supplementary: 2003 Bremer-exchange + elected-constitutional-council doctrine. en.wikiquote.org. Retrieved November 4, 2026, from https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ali_al-Sistani</answer>
Chicago (author-date)
al-Sistani, Grand Ayatollah Ali. 2003. "Ali al-Sistani — supplementary: 2003 Bremer-exchange + elected-constitutional-council doctrine." en.wikiquote.org. Accessed November 4, 2026. https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ali_al-Sistani</answer>.
BibTeX
@misc{doc-document-08d5c445-47a3-4f91-a780-f6814117f415,
  author       = {al-Sistani, Grand Ayatollah Ali},
  title        = {Ali al-Sistani — supplementary: 2003 Bremer-exchange + elected-constitutional-council doctrine},
  year         = {2003},
  date         = {2003-11-29},
  howpublished = {Online; hosted at en.wikiquote.org},
  url          = {https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ali_al-Sistani</answer>},
  urldate      = {2026-11-04},
  note         = {Retrieved via Tayyar at https://tarekgara.com/tayyar/documents/08d5c445-47a3-4f91-a780-f6814117f415},
}

Retrieved via Tayyar: https://tarekgara.com/tayyar/documents/08d5c445-47a3-4f91-a780-f6814117f415 on November 4, 2026. Tayyar is a research host for primary sources, not the author of this document.